>>412535234I think it is becaus seeing a potato onscreen is so unexpected, and claiming you can fit it up your ass is so unbelievable that people can't not pay attention.
Let's face it, however much we'd like to believe otherwise, girls don't go on omegle to look at cocks. And they probably don't go on to look at normal boring dudes either. They most likely are bored and looking for entertainment. So this guy with a potato comes along and they can't help but be drawn in because it is weird and entertaining.
However erotic OP finds it, the girls probably don't. They are probably just amazed/horrified he can do it. Except for the rare cases of girls looking to masturbate to something, the majority of them probably weren't planning at looking at some dudes junk, and probably would have disconnected had OP started with his junk out. What makes OP different is not that he is doing something different that girls secretly like, but that he is doing to same old webcam/junk combo but pulling it better with an interesting twist. I suspect that so many girls watched for the same reason that this thread has so many replies: not because we are turned on, but because OP's feat is weirdly awesome.