>>4406992For more masculine looking eyes, skip the whole eye-shadow/liner/mascara thing. If you must use mascara, use very little in a neutral color or use clear.
If you have naturally thin eyebrows, you'll need to thicken them up a bit by using an eyebrow pencil. Choose something close to your natural color or up to a shade lighter.
Your eyebrows don't have to match your wig color *exactly* unless you're doing a character with an unnatural hair color. You can either color over your eyebrows with make-up or you can look in to lightly bleaching your eyebrows.