Quoted By:
Ford and Chevy are the best you can get with Dodge not too far behind. Fords are higher quality as utilitarian vehicles, but Chevys will tend to be better work horses and can be beat up a lot more. Dodges aren't great quality but they get the job done.
The Japanese haven't made good trucks at all since the 80s. The Tundra is an absolute turd, Honda's Ridgline is useless, and the Nissan Titan can't even begin to compare with its American counterparts.
As far as mini trucks like the s10, Ranger, Dakota, etc, the s10 was just a re-badged Isuzu later in life, so it's garbage, don't know enough about the other to say, but chances are the Ford and Dodge are about equal.