Update 2024-03-27: Greatly expanded the "Samples" page and renamed it to "Glossary".
Update 2024-04-04: Added 5 million mid-2011 posts from the k47 post dump. Browse (mostly) them here.
Update 2024-04-07: Added ~400 October 2003 posts from 4chan.net. Browse them here.

Welcome to Oldfriend Archive, the official 4chan archive of the NSA. Hosting ~170M text-only 2003-2014 4chan posts (mostly 2006-2008).
[96 / 22 / ?]

No.14729460 View ViewReplyOriginalReport
This is how I tell if a medieval fantasy RPG is terrible.

If it uses any of the following terms: "full plate," "chainmail," "flail."
OR
If it uses the term "longsword" when it means "arming sword."

Then it is an awful medieval fantasy RPG. Every edition of D&D fails this test so badly by meeting all of the criteria above. If the writers don't bother doing their research on proper terminology for weapons and armor, how can they be expected to write a good setting or even a good game if they're that lazy and ignorant?