>>14752261Well, there are only two places you can get them: on ICs and on Company Commanders.
If your CCS is in a fight, it's fucked for a variety of reasons. Spending a bunch of points on a needless upgrade that won't change the outcome (and maybe won't even get to swing) is a poor choice.
Eldar S6 Fists suck, too. Eviscerators in the SoB/GK books are only okay because of 2d6 pen and other options to make them useful.
Don't get me wrong, they'll still kill a model or three when they come up, it's just not gonna happen a lot, won't change the outcome of what's going on, and take far more points than it's worth.
Now, if you're taking them for non-mechanical reasons... that's a different matter.